Italica
Gourmand100
Woody56
Musky28
Spicy24
SCENT COMPARISON
SIDE BY SIDE
Compare Scents
Compare verified fragrance details without the guesswork.
HOW DIFFERENT ARE THEY?
40% catalog similarity
There is some overlap, but their verified scent profiles are substantially different.
This is a ScentMarked catalog comparison based on verified notes and accord strength—not a clone determination, smell guarantee, or community vote.
SCENT DNA
Accord profile
Compare the strongest accord families in each fragrance. Strength values describe each scent's own profile and are not manufacturer concentration percentages.
DNA takeawayStrongest overlap: Gourmand · Woody · SpicyFloral: Shaghaf Oud Tonka is stronger (32 vs 0)Citrus: Shaghaf Oud Tonka is stronger (32 vs 0)Musky: Italica is stronger (28 vs 0)
Shaghaf Oud Tonka
Gourmand100
Woody35
Floral32
Spicy32
Citrus32
Top Notes
Italica
◆ Saffron
◆ Milky Notes
◆ Almond
Shaghaf Oud Tonka
◆ Almond
Heart Notes
Italica
◆ Toffee
◆ Bourbon Vanilla
Shaghaf Oud Tonka
◆ Cinnamon
◆ Turkish Rose
◆ Orange Blossom
Base Notes
Italica
◆ White Musk
◆ Sandalwood
◆ Cedarwood
Shaghaf Oud Tonka
◆ Vanilla
◆ Amberwood
◆ Tonka Bean
COMMUNITY COMPARISON
Community data is still building
No comparison votes yet. Consensus appears after at least 3 member votes.
COMMUNITY COMPARISON
Have you worn both?
Tell Scentmarked how these fragrances compare. Similarity runs from 1 (very different) to 5 (extremely similar). The other comparison questions are optional. Community votes are opinions, not verified manufacturer claims.